Re: Head replacement update
Posted: Sun Jul 15, 2012 2:43 am
Well, update time...
I put about 150miles on the car, and then I inspected the timing belt. Recall I "cut" my cover, so I can easily take off the top half and get a good view of the t-belt. I noticed that all the teeth on the belt had a scrape/cut about 1/4 inch from the edge of the belt. When I rebuilt the head, I changed out the gears on my cams, but Ieft the Aux and Crank gears in place, basically because I did not want to take off the crank nut after reading about what pain removing it can be. Anyway, after seeing marks on a brand new belt, I decided I would have to change out the Aux and Crank gear since one of them was gashing up my belts.
So, today I removed not 1, but 2 crank nuts. The first from my parts car to get a metal Aux gear (Bella had a worn plastic gear) and the second on Bella to change out the aux gear and the crank gear.
Crank nut 1 went smoothly. I blocked the tires, put the car in 5th, and had my dad step on the breaks. I then used a breaker bar with a 5.5 ft extension, rocked it a few times, and the nut came right off. Much easier than I expected...here is the breaker bar (a chainlink fence post) that I used. I put it next to a boogie board for scale.
With the nut off and the aux gear in hand, it was time to try the same routine on Bella - the first one was soooo easy. Not so for Bella. I used the same set up, but the nut would not come off. I tried and tried for about an hour - nothing. Leverage was not an issue, rather I concluded the clutch was slipping and the nut was not moving.
Next, I pulled out my Harbor Freight chain wrench. What a piece of garbage. First, the square hole was too small to properly fit my breaker, second, the chain was too small to go around the pulley. I gave up on using the chain after about 30 mins...
Leverage was not working, and I didn't have a functional chain wrench. I decided either I would have to 1) rent an impact wrench, or 2) attempt the dreaded "rope in the cylinder" trick. After much angst, I decided to go for the rope. First, I do not recommend this trick. If you do it wrong, you will bend your valves, and I just got done replacing the head because I bent all the valves... but here is what I did.
How To Remove your Crank Nut with the Rope in the Cylinder Trick.
1) Make sure your timing belt is on.
2) Rotate the crank so the crank timing mark is at 0 deg BTDC and the intake and exhaust cams are on their timing marks
3) Remove your distributor cap and make sure the rotor is pointing near/contacting cylinder plug #4
4) Ok, as I understand this, the engine is now set up so that #4 just finished compression and is waiting for a spark. It will then continue down in the power stroke. Thus, the full time during the up compression stroke and the full time in the down power stroke, the valves are completely closed. Thus it should be safe to do the rope trick on #4.
5) Remove your spark plug on #4. I then put a McDonalds straw in the spark plug hole to confirm #4 is TDC. Leave the straw in for step 6.
6) Rotate your crank clockwise (when viewing the engine straight on, this is the normal direction of engine rotation) until #4 drops to bottom dead center (BDC). Watch the straw. It will drop down while you crank the engine. When it stops moving down, you are at BDC.
7) Remove the straw, and then slowly feed in thin rope into #4 through the spark plug hole. Keep feeding in the rope until you "fill" the cylinder. Just keep feeding it until it doesn't want to take anymore rope.
Now slowly rotate the engine COUNTER CLOCKWISE (the opposite direction of normal rotation). Keep an eye on the timing marks on the crank and the cams. The rope should compress and then the engine should stop. It has to stop before #4 makes its way back to TDC or you did something wrong and you need to start over.
9) Once the engine gets hard to turn COUNTER CLOCKWISE, attach your breaker bar, and continue pushing counter clockwise to remove your crank nut. Mine made a loud "SNAP" sound, and I wasn't sure if I broke a tool or if the nut came loose. Fortunately, it was just the nut breaking loose with a loud noise. The crank nut is pictured below.
Ok - the rope trick worked, but I won't be 100% sure I didn't damage my engine until after I fire up Bella next week (waiting for parts...) Again, I don't recommend the rope method - if you do it wrong and bend valves, you are in for a major repair/project.
Ok, just when I thought things were going well, I could NOT get my Aux shaft bolt off. With the timing belt on, all the other cam bolts just cam off. This Aux bolt WOULD not budge, and as I tried to get it off, the gear would turn right through the teeth of the timing belt (i.e. slip through the teeth). I eventually took the t-belt off, and finally wrapped my lousy chain wrench around the Aux gear,(after hammering in a socket extension), and then I used a ratchet and my 5.5ft extension and FINALLY, the bolt came off. What a pain - I expect this to take 5 mins and instead I spent almost 2 hours.
Here is the final product with the crank shaft naked and cleaned...
And this is the what it looks like all aligned at TDC after installing the seal and the crank gear:
Notice how the dot on the crank gear aligns with the mark/line on the engine.
The crank gear was in rough shape. It had several issues, including a sharp blemish. I am pretty sure this gear was the culprit in damaging my brand new t-belt.
Anyway, I am waiting for aux and crank seals, new crank gear and a new t-belt to arrive. Hopefully early next week. Until then Bella will have to wait patiently. Hopefully now that I have new (or used) metal gears on both cams, the aux shaft and the crank shaft, I can finally stop worrying about t-belt issues for at least 20,000 miles.
Stay tuned.
I put about 150miles on the car, and then I inspected the timing belt. Recall I "cut" my cover, so I can easily take off the top half and get a good view of the t-belt. I noticed that all the teeth on the belt had a scrape/cut about 1/4 inch from the edge of the belt. When I rebuilt the head, I changed out the gears on my cams, but Ieft the Aux and Crank gears in place, basically because I did not want to take off the crank nut after reading about what pain removing it can be. Anyway, after seeing marks on a brand new belt, I decided I would have to change out the Aux and Crank gear since one of them was gashing up my belts.
So, today I removed not 1, but 2 crank nuts. The first from my parts car to get a metal Aux gear (Bella had a worn plastic gear) and the second on Bella to change out the aux gear and the crank gear.
Crank nut 1 went smoothly. I blocked the tires, put the car in 5th, and had my dad step on the breaks. I then used a breaker bar with a 5.5 ft extension, rocked it a few times, and the nut came right off. Much easier than I expected...here is the breaker bar (a chainlink fence post) that I used. I put it next to a boogie board for scale.
With the nut off and the aux gear in hand, it was time to try the same routine on Bella - the first one was soooo easy. Not so for Bella. I used the same set up, but the nut would not come off. I tried and tried for about an hour - nothing. Leverage was not an issue, rather I concluded the clutch was slipping and the nut was not moving.
Next, I pulled out my Harbor Freight chain wrench. What a piece of garbage. First, the square hole was too small to properly fit my breaker, second, the chain was too small to go around the pulley. I gave up on using the chain after about 30 mins...
Leverage was not working, and I didn't have a functional chain wrench. I decided either I would have to 1) rent an impact wrench, or 2) attempt the dreaded "rope in the cylinder" trick. After much angst, I decided to go for the rope. First, I do not recommend this trick. If you do it wrong, you will bend your valves, and I just got done replacing the head because I bent all the valves... but here is what I did.
How To Remove your Crank Nut with the Rope in the Cylinder Trick.
1) Make sure your timing belt is on.
2) Rotate the crank so the crank timing mark is at 0 deg BTDC and the intake and exhaust cams are on their timing marks
3) Remove your distributor cap and make sure the rotor is pointing near/contacting cylinder plug #4
4) Ok, as I understand this, the engine is now set up so that #4 just finished compression and is waiting for a spark. It will then continue down in the power stroke. Thus, the full time during the up compression stroke and the full time in the down power stroke, the valves are completely closed. Thus it should be safe to do the rope trick on #4.
5) Remove your spark plug on #4. I then put a McDonalds straw in the spark plug hole to confirm #4 is TDC. Leave the straw in for step 6.
6) Rotate your crank clockwise (when viewing the engine straight on, this is the normal direction of engine rotation) until #4 drops to bottom dead center (BDC). Watch the straw. It will drop down while you crank the engine. When it stops moving down, you are at BDC.
7) Remove the straw, and then slowly feed in thin rope into #4 through the spark plug hole. Keep feeding in the rope until you "fill" the cylinder. Just keep feeding it until it doesn't want to take anymore rope.
Now slowly rotate the engine COUNTER CLOCKWISE (the opposite direction of normal rotation). Keep an eye on the timing marks on the crank and the cams. The rope should compress and then the engine should stop. It has to stop before #4 makes its way back to TDC or you did something wrong and you need to start over.
9) Once the engine gets hard to turn COUNTER CLOCKWISE, attach your breaker bar, and continue pushing counter clockwise to remove your crank nut. Mine made a loud "SNAP" sound, and I wasn't sure if I broke a tool or if the nut came loose. Fortunately, it was just the nut breaking loose with a loud noise. The crank nut is pictured below.
Ok - the rope trick worked, but I won't be 100% sure I didn't damage my engine until after I fire up Bella next week (waiting for parts...) Again, I don't recommend the rope method - if you do it wrong and bend valves, you are in for a major repair/project.
Ok, just when I thought things were going well, I could NOT get my Aux shaft bolt off. With the timing belt on, all the other cam bolts just cam off. This Aux bolt WOULD not budge, and as I tried to get it off, the gear would turn right through the teeth of the timing belt (i.e. slip through the teeth). I eventually took the t-belt off, and finally wrapped my lousy chain wrench around the Aux gear,(after hammering in a socket extension), and then I used a ratchet and my 5.5ft extension and FINALLY, the bolt came off. What a pain - I expect this to take 5 mins and instead I spent almost 2 hours.
Here is the final product with the crank shaft naked and cleaned...
And this is the what it looks like all aligned at TDC after installing the seal and the crank gear:
Notice how the dot on the crank gear aligns with the mark/line on the engine.
The crank gear was in rough shape. It had several issues, including a sharp blemish. I am pretty sure this gear was the culprit in damaging my brand new t-belt.
Anyway, I am waiting for aux and crank seals, new crank gear and a new t-belt to arrive. Hopefully early next week. Until then Bella will have to wait patiently. Hopefully now that I have new (or used) metal gears on both cams, the aux shaft and the crank shaft, I can finally stop worrying about t-belt issues for at least 20,000 miles.
Stay tuned.