Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

General chat about the car goes in here.
Post Reply
Tango

Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by Tango »

Have I got this right?
Looking at some other threads and then going out and trying to see what was happening with the heater, I think I have this figured out, which I could NOT do while driving the other evening with the windshield starting to mist up. Probably because I couldn't figure out at all what lever 1 did.

Numbering from left to right with the three heater controls, No. 1 opens up the outside air source to the fan. No. 2 controls the heater water valve. Moving toward the red makes it cooler and towards the blue (fwd) makes it cooler relatively. No. 3 switches air from defrost (which has a symbol) to the floor vents (which have none).

Someone's advice that you have to look at the triangles as "less than" and "more than" math-type symbols make sense now.

None of this was in any of the reference materials I have managed to put together so far.

It's quirky. I like that.

T
ROOK1

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by ROOK1 »

Bump to the correct century.
pope

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by pope »

There are three levers for air and heat

1. lever next to the driver is air volume. Pulled all the way back gives you max. air flow. Pushed forward closes air flow.

2. lever just to the right of first lever is heater control. Pulled back gives no heat, just outside air temp. Pushed forward gives you max. heat.

3. lever on far right all by itself, is diverter. Pulled back, it allows air to flow through the upper circular dash vents, pushed forward allows air to flow through upper dash and lower feet vents.

Air is always diverted to dash vents in all instances, unless you close air volume in step 1.
Tango

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by Tango »

Sorry, this doubles up on another post I made last night. Something strange happened in that it got registered as having been written many years ago but I thought it had just disappeared into the ether (my computer was otherwise freezing up trying to upload photo's, so that didnt seem that odd).

But I appreciate the clarification.
zachmac
Posts: 1278
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:20 am
Your car is a: 1978 Spider [1979 2 ltr engine]
Location: Aiken, SC

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by zachmac »

pope wrote:There are three levers for air and heat

2. lever just to the right of first lever is heater control. Pulled back gives no heat, just outside air temp. Pushed forward gives you max. heat.

Air is always diverted to dash vents in all instances, unless you close air volume in step 1.
All correct EXCEPT that on my car the heater control valve works exactly the opposite, forward is valve full open (max heat) and pulled all the way back / up if heater control valve closed (no heat). I wonder if I somehow I intalled it backwards since this is clearly contrary to what the red / blue seems to indicate would make sense? However, there was only one way that valve would mount so I don't know?
Jeff Klein, Aiken, SC
1980 FI Spider, Veridian with Tan (sold about a year ago), in the market for another project
1989 Spider, sold
2008 Mercedes SL65
2008 S600 Mercedes V12
Tango

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by Tango »

But if you move the temperature lever fwd, you are moving it towards the blue (presumably colder) setting, right? That would make more sense to me.

Just to clarify, the red triangle is towards the rear (lever up position) and the blue is toward the front on mine.

I have to say, I think the advice now is split about 50/50 with two people saying that all levers forward is heat shut off and air closed, but one or two saying heat lever is at the "valve closed" position when rearwards.
zachmac
Posts: 1278
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:20 am
Your car is a: 1978 Spider [1979 2 ltr engine]
Location: Aiken, SC

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by zachmac »

Tango wrote:But if you move the temperature lever fwd, you are moving it towards the blue (presumably colder) setting, right? That would make more sense to me.

Just to clarify, the red triangle is towards the rear (lever up position) and the blue is toward the front on mine.

I have to say, I think the advice now is split about 50/50 with two people saying that all levers forward is heat shut off and air closed, but one or two saying heat lever is at the "valve closed" position when rearwards.
I don't know what is correct but I do KNOW that with my valve in my hand connected to the lever (off the heater core) the lever pulled back to the red is valve closed (no heat) and forward toward the blue is valve open (max heat) which I agree is totally counterintuitive to what red and blue should mean.
Jeff Klein, Aiken, SC
1980 FI Spider, Veridian with Tan (sold about a year ago), in the market for another project
1989 Spider, sold
2008 Mercedes SL65
2008 S600 Mercedes V12
zachmac
Posts: 1278
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:20 am
Your car is a: 1978 Spider [1979 2 ltr engine]
Location: Aiken, SC

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by zachmac »

If you go to the "Related Links" section on this site there is a post that links to PDF manuals and documents as well as jpeg captures of owners manuals (very helpful if you haven't found it!!!). On Page 13 of the 2000 Spider owner's manual it says that seccond lever (Lever D in page 12 diagram):

Pulled all back - no heating of air
Pushed all forward - maximum heating of air

That seems to confirm the way my car works, pulled all back (upright toward rear of car) shuts the heater water inlet valve and shuts OFF heat, exactly the opposite of what I would think looking at blue versus red labels.
Jeff Klein, Aiken, SC
1980 FI Spider, Veridian with Tan (sold about a year ago), in the market for another project
1989 Spider, sold
2008 Mercedes SL65
2008 S600 Mercedes V12
zachmac
Posts: 1278
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:20 am
Your car is a: 1978 Spider [1979 2 ltr engine]
Location: Aiken, SC

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by zachmac »

zachmac wrote:
pope wrote:There are three levers for air and heat

2. lever just to the right of first lever is heater control. Pulled back gives no heat, just outside air temp. Pushed forward gives you max. heat.

Air is always diverted to dash vents in all instances, unless you close air volume in step 1.
All correct EXCEPT that on my car the heater control valve works exactly the opposite, forward is valve full open (max heat) and pulled all the way back / up if heater control valve closed (no heat). I wonder if I somehow I intalled it backwards since this is clearly contrary to what the red / blue seems to indicate would make sense? However, there was only one way that valve would mount so I don't know?
My bad, my lever works exactly as pope described (and I described) I just failed to recognize he said the same thing.
Jeff Klein, Aiken, SC
1980 FI Spider, Veridian with Tan (sold about a year ago), in the market for another project
1989 Spider, sold
2008 Mercedes SL65
2008 S600 Mercedes V12
Tango

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by Tango »

Ah, mystery solved. And thank you for referring me to that RElated Links page, that is exactly what I am looking for right now, a copy of the Owner's Manual, among other things.

Tim
rlux4
Patron 2022
Patron 2022
Posts: 4211
Joined: Thu Jan 10, 2008 8:32 pm
Your car is a: 1982 2000 Spider
Location: Granite Falls, Wa

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by rlux4 »

So that your brain isn't constantly reversing the intuitive meaning of the symbols, Mike (mbouse) cleared it up a while back to my great satisfaction. It's the shape, not the color of the triangles that have the most meaning. Towards the point (small end) of the triangle is least, towards the base (larger end) is most. Same applies to either air flow, or heat.
Ron
Ron Luxmore
rlux2n2@gmail.com
'82 2000 Spider: after 26 years between Spiders.
joelbert2k

Re: Heater Control Wins Counter-intuitive design award

Post by joelbert2k »

That's the best way to look at it. Also the blue relates to the air flow which is always cool(er), unless you live in AZ or the Antelope Vally, and red for heat.
Joel
Post Reply